Calamari is probably one of the most popular appetizers at restaurants. I know my friends and family almost always have an order if it’s available on the menu. That doesn’t mean that every order of calamari is equal in the mouth of the beholder. There are a variety of ways to make the dish. Some restaurants over-bread their calamari by using flour, eggs, and breadcrumbs. That’s a good way to ensure a crispy outside and that the calamari retains it’s shape without breading falling off. Nonetheless, that can often feel like the heavy breading is the star of the show while the calamari is a rubbery sidekick. Other restaurants sometimes barely bread the calamari at all, which highlights the squid, but can often mean soggy breading that just falls off as it’s plated.
In this recipe, I took the middle ground and used a light breading, but also used milk or buttermilk to tenderize the calamari. This also allowed the breading to really adhere to the squid’s smooth surface. Marinating seafood in milk might sound strange, but it’s a great way to remove fishiness from items that may be frozen or less than fresh as well. The combination of using flour only and milk as a tenderizing binding agent really makes this dish rival some restaurant preparations. That means you too can have restaurant quality calamari at home! The other added benefit to the simple preparation is that the recipe is customizable because you can add your own spices to the flour or flavors to the marinade to change things up between batches.
Some other seafood recipes from Man Fuel to try:
- Fried Shrimp Po’ Boy Sandwiches with Remoulade Sauce
- New England Style Lobster Roll
- Shrimp and Scallop Ceviche
- Steamed Mussels with Chourico
Homemade Lightly Fried Calamari
Fried Calamari with dipping sauces.
- 1 pound of raw calamari/squid cut into rings
- 2 cups of milk or buttermilk (or enough to cover the calamari)
- 1/2 cup of flour (optionally, try a 1/4 cup of flour mixed with a 1/4 of cornmeal for a more Southern style)
- 1/2 teaspoon baking powder
- 1/8 teaspoon ground black pepper
- 1/8 teaspoon salt
- Canola or vegetable oil (enough to fill an inch deep in a pot or pan)
- Optional Ingredients:
- 1 teaspoon onion powder
- 1/2 teaspoon paprika
- 2 chopped garlic cloves
- Banana pepper rings
- Small pot or pan with raised sides
- Slotted spoon/spatula or spider spatula
- Wide, shallow bowl
- Large bowl
- 2 large plates
- Paper towels or fine wire cooling rack
- Two forks or two chopsticks
- Cup and teaspoon measurements
- If you have fresh calamari, great. If not, make sure to let it defrost before you try to make this recipe. I won’t go over how to prep a squid into rings, so I’ll assume you already have calamari rings.
- Take the calamari rings (and legs if you want), place them in a bowl, and cover with whole milk or buttermilk. This step not only helps to remove any fishiness often found in frozen calamari, but it helps to tenderize it so that it doesn’t get too rubbery during the cooking process. Let the calamari soak covered in the fridge for at least 4 hours or ideally overnight.
- Optional Step: If you want to flavor the milk/buttermilk to add a little something extra to the calamari, you can do that by adding two roughly chopped garlic cloves to the milk or any other flavor you think might complement the calamari.
- After the calamari is marinated, place a 1/2 cup of flour into a bowl and mix it together with the 1/2 teaspoon of baking powder (this helps to puff up the flour a bit and keep it crispy), the 1/8 teaspoon of salt, and the 1/8 teaspoon of black pepper.
- Optional Step: You can add other flavors to the flour to customize the calamari. Try adding 1 teaspoon of onion powder and a 1/2 teaspoon of paprika for some variety. You can add other flavors as well if you’re feeling particularly creative.
- Use one fork or chopstick to transfer a couple of calamari rings right from the milk/buttermilk to the flour and use another fork or chopstick (a dry one that hasn’t touched the calamari) to dredge them in the flour. You can also use your hands if you want to dredge the calamari rings. The idea is to keep the wet utensils away from the flour to avoid clumping. After dredging the calamari rings in the flour, transfer the calamari to a large plate or tray. Don’t let the pieces touch one another. Repeat this process for all of the calamari.
- Optional Step: You can also dredge banana peppers in the flour to fry later. The pepper rings add a tangy and mildly spicy variety to the dish. You can mix them in with the calamari or keep them on the side. You don’t need to bread them either. You can leave them as they are and toss them with the fried calamari. You can also saute them with some olive oil and garlic to create a topping for the calamari. In some circles, this preparation of combining banana peppers with calamari is called Rhode Island-Style Calamari.
- With the calamari breaded, place enough canola or vegetable oil in a small pot or deep pan to have about an inch of depth. Heat the oil to 350 degrees F (that’s roughly the medium heat setting on a stove if you don’t have a thermometer).
- Once the oil is hot enough, add a few calamari to the oil to fry. If you don’t have a thermometer you can roughly tell when the oil is hot enough once you can see it shimmer a bit. If you place the end of a wooden spoon or chopstick into the oil and it bubbles, then it’s ready to go. It’s very important that you don’t overcrowd the pot or the calamari will steam and the breading will just get soggy. Just put a few at at time so that they don’t really touch.
- Let the calamari fry on one side for about three minutes. Then carefully flip them to finish frying for another 1-2 minutes. Watch the color of the breading. You’re shooting for golden or golden brown and crispy. If it gets too dark too fast, then the oil may be too hot. If it seems to just remain soggy or fall off the calamari after a couple of minutes, then the oil may be too cold.
- Use a slotted spoon or spider spatula to remove the calamari and place them either on a fine wire cooling rack (preferred) or a wide plate lined with some paper towels to absorb the excess oil. Repeat the process to fry all of the calamari. Between batches, you should try and skim out any noticeable burned pieces of breading that may still be in the oil. If you prepared the banana pepper rings, then fry them after the calamari the same way.
- Plate the calamari and serve along with your favorite dipping sauce. Some sauce suggestions are: marinara, tartar, creamy chipotle, remoulade, and hot sauce. You can even use the calamari as a topper for other dishes like zoodles (spiralized zucchini noodles) sauteed in butter and garlic. As for the purists out there, you can try just a squeeze of fresh lemon on top of the calamari.
Please Support Man Fuel!
If you enjoyed this recipe, please support Man Fuel Food Blog by subscribing to receive updates on the latest posts.
No spam. Just real updates on recipes, restaurant reviews, travel, and free giveaways!